Orange alternatives were fire get them out of this discussion.
In my opinion the black jerseys are ugliest by far. Stadium series is fine for a stadium series jersey lol. Bottom left is also fine too, not my fav but they’re fine. Orange is fire
shockwave-315
Black. Every time Black. This will never change. 🤢🤮
olah711
Top left, too much black without doing anything interesting with thr space other than horizontal letters
HidingWithBigFoot
The first one
Brawl-legends
top left
Jace214291
Fisherman, no question
Kzx45uH3nz
– The black one is so ugly that I kind of have to like it.
– The orange one is also fairly ugly but at least it was trying something new.
– The bottom left ones are just eh but honestly I don’t hate the dark blue especially because it reminds me of the earlier 2000-04 jerseys I grew up on.
– The ISLES jerseys are honestly nice. The colors seem to look a lot better in some photos than others.
tomek142
Top left 🤮🤢
EfficiencyHuge1946
The Fisherman. Anyone who lives through that era understands there’s no other answer. Anyone young enough not to have endured those years of misery just doesn’t get it fully.
Nicks-Dad
I still hate the Fisherman.
ramen_sukidesu
Capt Highliner jersey was the worst. Players specifically asked the NYI to be on their no trade list because of those jersey’s
yankfan2426
Top left, even Dipietro on his radio show says how the players hated it and whenever they saw it in the lockers they knew they were gonna lose that night
shong109
Either top ones
davidkuchar
love how fisherman won the vote completely as a write-in to this disingenuous post
longesteveryeahboy
Upper left and it’s not even fucking close. So bad
DefeatTh3Purpose
Upper right has that ” ye olde tyme” feel to it but it just makes me think of that upset at the stadium, upper left is dumb. I don’t mind the others. Nothing beats the good ol white with blue and orange. A classic. A fine wine. Poifeck.
azisles02
The black jersey.
I love the orange (actually 1 blank & 1 with my name/number one in it) & I actually liked the 07 jerseys
doodyballz
Black ones in top left. Disgusting
Barzal-13
Am I the only one who liked the 2008-2010 jerseys? I know the Reebok edge 1.0 redesigns don’t sit well with many people but as someone who grew up having the 2009-10 team be their first, they have a special place for me.
I really don’t consider any of these jerseys to be bad.
luvs2plae
Anything that has that stupid fisherman
C_Gull27
Top left are so ugly. The gray just looks so bad with our color scheme. I don’t like black on our kits either and this has both.
agentanthony
Top two and bottom left. The orange alt was pretty cool and also very popular.
No_Paramedic_2039
So many choices. So little time.
Radu47
Top left is at least an interesting and unique colour scheme
Radu47
I think ultimately it has to be top right as not only being aesthetically bleh but also conceptually in that it’s classic soulless faux retro kinda malarkey
Mejormccheese
the obsession this team had with shoulder patches on the thirds my god
TKWylde
None of these. The all black Brooklyn jerseys were the absolute worst of all time.
28 Comments
Top left and it’s not even close
Orange alternatives were fire get them out of this discussion.
In my opinion the black jerseys are ugliest by far. Stadium series is fine for a stadium series jersey lol. Bottom left is also fine too, not my fav but they’re fine. Orange is fire
Black. Every time Black. This will never change. 🤢🤮
Top left, too much black without doing anything interesting with thr space other than horizontal letters
The first one
top left
Fisherman, no question
– The black one is so ugly that I kind of have to like it.
– The orange one is also fairly ugly but at least it was trying something new.
– The bottom left ones are just eh but honestly I don’t hate the dark blue especially because it reminds me of the earlier 2000-04 jerseys I grew up on.
– The ISLES jerseys are honestly nice. The colors seem to look a lot better in some photos than others.
Top left 🤮🤢
The Fisherman. Anyone who lives through that era understands there’s no other answer. Anyone young enough not to have endured those years of misery just doesn’t get it fully.
I still hate the Fisherman.
Capt Highliner jersey was the worst. Players specifically asked the NYI to be on their no trade list because of those jersey’s
Top left, even Dipietro on his radio show says how the players hated it and whenever they saw it in the lockers they knew they were gonna lose that night
Either top ones
love how fisherman won the vote completely as a write-in to this disingenuous post
Upper left and it’s not even fucking close. So bad
Upper right has that ” ye olde tyme” feel to it but it just makes me think of that upset at the stadium, upper left is dumb. I don’t mind the others. Nothing beats the good ol white with blue and orange. A classic. A fine wine. Poifeck.
The black jersey.
I love the orange (actually 1 blank & 1 with my name/number one in it) & I actually liked the 07 jerseys
Black ones in top left. Disgusting
Am I the only one who liked the 2008-2010 jerseys?
I know the Reebok edge 1.0 redesigns don’t sit well with many people but as someone who grew up having the 2009-10 team be their first, they have a special place for me.
I really don’t consider any of these jerseys to be bad.
Anything that has that stupid fisherman
Top left are so ugly. The gray just looks so bad with our color scheme. I don’t like black on our kits either and this has both.
Top two and bottom left. The orange alt was pretty cool and also very popular.
So many choices. So little time.
Top left is at least an interesting and unique colour scheme
I think ultimately it has to be top right as not only being aesthetically bleh but also conceptually in that it’s classic soulless faux retro kinda malarkey
the obsession this team had with shoulder patches on the thirds my god
None of these. The all black Brooklyn jerseys were the absolute worst of all time.