Mr. Cirelli has to at least be in the conversation here.
Enough-Register5313
Killer
Karmakakez
Probably Point but he hasn’t had to in a long time
ACMop
Cirelli is one of the best shutdown centres in the league, not really too many comparable players who also play Top 6 minutes in the team’s past. Gotta be him
noodleyone
Vinny as a Power Forward? Wtf.
Allen_Koholic
Cirelli. He’s the only Tampa player I remember ever being talked about in Selke terms.
Kdoubleaa
It’s 100% Palat.
dj-kitty
Yanni Gourde
FLTBR
Cirelli or Killorn
DuckTruckMuck
Right now could be Hagel. He is on PP, PK1 and was #2 in the league in takeaways last year. But not a center so maybe it leans Cirelli for that reason.
2ndprize
Im voting Palat. But Im fine with Gourde or Zamuner.
FernandinaRed
Palat
FUPaladin11
TONY!!! #71, baby!
R_O_Bison
People already forgetting our boy Pally! Only man on the top line to play that D.
CentralAlmond
Palat
CaptainNicko83
Palat, then Killer, then Cirelli for me. Honorable mention for Yanni, but he us left too soon.
tonyturtle19
Palat
Basil_Normal
Kinda interesting, we’ve had some dominant defensive teams, but there’s not really a dominant two way forward that sticks out to me. Cirelli is probably the best defensive forward but calling him a two way guy is a bit of a stretch imo.
I looked back at Selke voting histories to try and see if I was missing anyone obvious. Cirelli is definitely our best finisher. Point had a couple of pretty high finishes early in his career but his defense has really fallen off in recent years. MSL received votes a few times as did Palat and Tyler Johnson (another guy who kinda fell off a cliff).
Perhaps the funniest/most surprising thing I noticed. Kuch received Selke votes in 2015 and 2017. Suck it all those Avs and Leafs that say he can’t play defense
Beeriggz
Palat
Jbooth72
Cirelli
DangerWildMan26
Palat
RenBoutch91
Cirelli or Gourde are two great candidates but we really had a lot of great 2way players in recent years
thebigsad72
cirelli
mishey22
100% Anthony Cirelli
GatorBolt
Zamuner deserves more votes despite being a while ago
![New York Islanders vs New York Rangers [ GAME 1st]Sept 24,2024 | NHL Today |2024 NHL Preseason | NHL](https://www.lovenhl.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/1729148769_maxresdefault-150x150.jpg)
25 Comments
Mr. Cirelli has to at least be in the conversation here.
Killer
Probably Point but he hasn’t had to in a long time
Cirelli is one of the best shutdown centres in the league, not really too many comparable players who also play Top 6 minutes in the team’s past. Gotta be him
Vinny as a Power Forward? Wtf.
Cirelli. He’s the only Tampa player I remember ever being talked about in Selke terms.
It’s 100% Palat.
Yanni Gourde
Cirelli or Killorn
Right now could be Hagel. He is on PP, PK1 and was #2 in the league in takeaways last year. But not a center so maybe it leans Cirelli for that reason.
Im voting Palat. But Im fine with Gourde or Zamuner.
Palat
TONY!!! #71, baby!
People already forgetting our boy Pally! Only man on the top line to play that D.
Palat
Palat, then Killer, then Cirelli for me. Honorable mention for Yanni, but he us left too soon.
Palat
Kinda interesting, we’ve had some dominant defensive teams, but there’s not really a dominant two way forward that sticks out to me. Cirelli is probably the best defensive forward but calling him a two way guy is a bit of a stretch imo.
I looked back at Selke voting histories to try and see if I was missing anyone obvious. Cirelli is definitely our best finisher. Point had a couple of pretty high finishes early in his career but his defense has really fallen off in recent years. MSL received votes a few times as did Palat and Tyler Johnson (another guy who kinda fell off a cliff).
Perhaps the funniest/most surprising thing I noticed. Kuch received Selke votes in 2015 and 2017. Suck it all those Avs and Leafs that say he can’t play defense
Palat
Cirelli
Palat
Cirelli or Gourde are two great candidates but we really had a lot of great 2way players in recent years
cirelli
100% Anthony Cirelli
Zamuner deserves more votes despite being a while ago