for the last time, yes. no doubt. please stop asking.
KantanaBrigantei
Yes.
Next question?
HabChronicle
If Lundqvist made it, so will Carey
Technerd70
Just delete the thread.
0bl1v10n204
I literally just put a comment about this yesterday in the nhl sub and people agree. His resume is thorough and he deserves it, without a doubt. First ballot if you ask me.
WintertimeLivingEasy
Yea, and habs should retire his jersey.
burnSMACKER
Yes. It’s not even an argument. Stop.
AmsroII
Literally = Not yet
Almost certainly after he’s retired = Yes
DIKs_Steeler
Any goaltender winning the Hart should be considered, ~~Theodore being the exception that prove the rule~~ (there’s also Al Rollins in the 50’s, but idk what happened here; [he finished the season with 12 wins and 47 loses and 3,23 avg](https://www.nhl.com/news/al-rollins-wins-hart-trophy-with-chicago/c-308307676))
Price stayed consistant and his Cup final run in 20-21 (plus the run where he got injured by Kreider) were both “Stanley cup winner worthy”.
edit: I guess it’s not a saying anymore?
[deleted]
[deleted]
jadenspan
Gold Medal, Veznia, Hart, multiple all-star, SCF
philjitsu
It’s the Hockey Hall of Fame, not the NHL Hall of Fame. Price has won world Junior and Olympic gold. Personal NHL awards and won the Calder cup with the Hamilton Bulldogs.
He holds the record for most wins for a goalie for a franchise older than the NHL.
He’s getting in when he officially retires no questions asked.
Will the Habs retire 31? That’s much more debatable..
If 31 won’t be retired for just Price I hope we get lucky enough to have another goalie take 31 to the rafters on cup wins in the next decade so maybe a dual 31 retirement is possible.
Personally I would be okay with the Habs retiring 31 for Price. Even if he didn’t get his cup.
Thank you goalie Carey <3
a7xgemzy
What a stupid question. Yes he is.
GreatWhiteNorth4
I’m so tired of this debate. Unequivocally the answer is yes. It’s not just the NHL hall of fame, it’s the *hockey* hall of fame.
He’s the all time winningest goaltender in the history of the Canadiens, the most successful franchise in the league historically speaking. Had a run of dominance in net from 2013-2017 we may not see again (especially without a top tier team in front of said goalie, which we didn’t have). The awards sweep in 2015. 7 time all star. And to top it all off? He’s got a WJC gold, World Cup gold, and an Olympic gold. With his totals from the senior tourneys being 10-0 with a nuts GAA and save percentage. If anything that’s a first ballot hall of famer lol 🤷🏻♂️
BackgroundMiserable5
Yes.
txe88
Yes. A no brainer.
Cdn_Medic
Yeah, it’s not a question of if he gets in or not, the question is is he first ballot or not.
I think he is, but I wouldn’t be surprised if his lack of cup, will see him wait a year or two of eligibility.
MustardTiger1337
No
poa1991
This is weekly debate again. Yes to HOF but no to rafters.
endpointanalytics
Nope.
theflower10
Not even a question. Of course he is. He should be in the year he is eligible.
sex_panther_by_odeon
That question is an easy yes. The harder question is should his number be retired. There are valid points on both sides of the argument on that one.
hiptragicallybroken
I’d give it to him yesterday so we could just move on.
BigBoy990
100%, especially after this years class.
Nerav256
Definitely.
RGM81
World Juniors MVP, Olympics MVP, Vezina/Hart/Lindsay season, all-time Habs leader in goalie wins, he’s got everything except Stanley.
goompa88
Yes. The only thing he didn’t win was the cup . He’s in first ballot.
millennial101
Yes
DJP-MTL
Yes
Visual-Ad-3503
Frontrunner for worst question of all time by now.
hockeynoticehockey
CP is a lock for the HoF, for nothing else than his performances in net for Team Canada.
The one and only thing he didn’t get was the Cup
lyme6483
Easily yes
Aabbppll
There’s no denying that Price has had an impressive career with the Montreal Canadiens, but when we place his career stats and accolades in context with other notable goalies, both past and present, does his HHoF argument hold up?
Let’s start with Price’s key statistics: a career save percentage (SV%) of .917 and a goals against average (GAA) of 2.50. His list of accolades includes one Vezina Trophy (best goaltender, 2014-15) and one Jennings Trophy (fewest goals scored against, 2014-15). While these stats and awards are indeed commendable, they become less remarkable when compared to other accomplished goalies who are not in the Hall.
Consider, for instance, Jaroslav Halak. Despite playing fewer games, Halak has a comparable SV% (.916) and GAA (2.48). His best season save percentage (.931) is almost identical to Price’s best (.933). And let’s not forget the 2009-10 playoff season where Halak outperformed Price, claiming the starting spot and carrying the Canadiens deep into the playoffs. This comparison is not meant to diminish Price’s accomplishments but to emphasize that the gap between these two players, one often considered for the HHoF and the other not, may not be as wide as perceived.
Moreover, several other goalies with noteworthy careers are still waiting for their call to the HHoF, many with stats and accolades surpassing or rivaling Price’s. Here are a few:
1. Curtis Joseph: 5th all-time in wins with 454, and an era-adjusted SV% that matches Price’s.
2. Tom Barrasso: Two-time Stanley Cup champion, Vezina Trophy, and William M. Jennings Trophy winner.
3. Mike Vernon: Two-time Stanley Cup champion and Conn Smythe winner.
4. Chris Osgood: Three-time Stanley Cup champion with two Jennings Trophies.
5. Miikka Kiprusoff: Vezina Trophy winner with two Jennings Trophies and an impressive Stanley Cup finals run.
Each of these goaltenders has left a significant mark on their and their career achievements present compelling cases for HHoF induction. If these goalies are still waiting for their call, it raises some valid questions about Price’s candidacy.
To reiterate, this is not an attempt to undermine Price’s contributions or talent, but rather to add depth and perspective to the discussion around his HHoF candidacy. The comparison highlights the high bar that’s been set by other goaltenders, reminding us that HHoF induction is a significant honor bestowed upon the truly elite.
LongBoyLobster
1st ballot
Shoresy514
Without a doubt. Should the Habs retire his jersey? That’s up for debate.
RSlashLazy
Easily. 4th best all time (fight me), and the best to never win a cup. If Hank gets in, so will Price.
36 Comments
for the last time, yes. no doubt. please stop asking.
Yes.
Next question?
If Lundqvist made it, so will Carey
Just delete the thread.
I literally just put a comment about this yesterday in the nhl sub and people agree. His resume is thorough and he deserves it, without a doubt. First ballot if you ask me.
Yea, and habs should retire his jersey.
Yes. It’s not even an argument. Stop.
Literally = Not yet
Almost certainly after he’s retired = Yes
Any goaltender winning the Hart should be considered, ~~Theodore being the exception that prove the rule~~ (there’s also Al Rollins in the 50’s, but idk what happened here; [he finished the season with 12 wins and 47 loses and 3,23 avg](https://www.nhl.com/news/al-rollins-wins-hart-trophy-with-chicago/c-308307676))
Price stayed consistant and his Cup final run in 20-21 (plus the run where he got injured by Kreider) were both “Stanley cup winner worthy”.
edit: I guess it’s not a saying anymore?
[deleted]
Gold Medal, Veznia, Hart, multiple all-star, SCF
It’s the Hockey Hall of Fame, not the NHL Hall of Fame.
Price has won world Junior and Olympic gold. Personal NHL awards and won the Calder cup with the Hamilton Bulldogs.
He holds the record for most wins for a goalie for a franchise older than the NHL.
He’s getting in when he officially retires no questions asked.
Will the Habs retire 31? That’s much more debatable..
If 31 won’t be retired for just Price I hope we get lucky enough to have another goalie take 31 to the rafters on cup wins in the next decade so maybe a dual 31 retirement is possible.
Personally I would be okay with the Habs retiring 31 for Price. Even if he didn’t get his cup.
Thank you goalie Carey <3
What a stupid question. Yes he is.
I’m so tired of this debate. Unequivocally the answer is yes. It’s not just the NHL hall of fame, it’s the *hockey* hall of fame.
He’s the all time winningest goaltender in the history of the Canadiens, the most successful franchise in the league historically speaking. Had a run of dominance in net from 2013-2017 we may not see again (especially without a top tier team in front of said goalie, which we didn’t have). The awards sweep in 2015. 7 time all star. And to top it all off? He’s got a WJC gold, World Cup gold, and an Olympic gold. With his totals from the senior tourneys being 10-0 with a nuts GAA and save percentage. If anything that’s a first ballot hall of famer lol 🤷🏻♂️
Yes.
Yes. A no brainer.
Yeah, it’s not a question of if he gets in or not, the question is is he first ballot or not.
I think he is, but I wouldn’t be surprised if his lack of cup, will see him wait a year or two of eligibility.
No
This is weekly debate again. Yes to HOF but no to rafters.
Nope.
Not even a question. Of course he is. He should be in the year he is eligible.
That question is an easy yes. The harder question is should his number be retired. There are valid points on both sides of the argument on that one.
I’d give it to him yesterday so we could just move on.
100%, especially after this years class.
Definitely.
World Juniors MVP, Olympics MVP, Vezina/Hart/Lindsay season, all-time Habs leader in goalie wins, he’s got everything except Stanley.
Yes. The only thing he didn’t win was the cup . He’s in first ballot.
Yes
Yes
Frontrunner for worst question of all time by now.
CP is a lock for the HoF, for nothing else than his performances in net for Team Canada.
The one and only thing he didn’t get was the Cup
Easily yes
There’s no denying that Price has had an impressive career with the Montreal Canadiens, but when we place his career stats and accolades in context with other notable goalies, both past and present, does his HHoF argument hold up?
Let’s start with Price’s key statistics: a career save percentage (SV%) of .917 and a goals against average (GAA) of 2.50. His list of accolades includes one Vezina Trophy (best goaltender, 2014-15) and one Jennings Trophy (fewest goals scored against, 2014-15). While these stats and awards are indeed commendable, they become less remarkable when compared to other accomplished goalies who are not in the Hall.
Consider, for instance, Jaroslav Halak. Despite playing fewer games, Halak has a comparable SV% (.916) and GAA (2.48). His best season save percentage (.931) is almost identical to Price’s best (.933). And let’s not forget the 2009-10 playoff season where Halak outperformed Price, claiming the starting spot and carrying the Canadiens deep into the playoffs. This comparison is not meant to diminish Price’s accomplishments but to emphasize that the gap between these two players, one often considered for the HHoF and the other not, may not be as wide as perceived.
Moreover, several other goalies with noteworthy careers are still waiting for their call to the HHoF, many with stats and accolades surpassing or rivaling Price’s. Here are a few:
1. Curtis Joseph: 5th all-time in wins with 454, and an era-adjusted SV% that matches Price’s.
2. Tom Barrasso: Two-time Stanley Cup champion, Vezina Trophy, and William M. Jennings Trophy winner.
3. Mike Vernon: Two-time Stanley Cup champion and Conn Smythe winner.
4. Chris Osgood: Three-time Stanley Cup champion with two Jennings Trophies.
5. Miikka Kiprusoff: Vezina Trophy winner with two Jennings Trophies and an impressive Stanley Cup finals run.
Each of these goaltenders has left a significant mark on their and their career achievements present compelling cases for HHoF induction. If these goalies are still waiting for their call, it raises some valid questions about Price’s candidacy.
To reiterate, this is not an attempt to undermine Price’s contributions or talent, but rather to add depth and perspective to the discussion around his HHoF candidacy. The comparison highlights the high bar that’s been set by other goaltenders, reminding us that HHoF induction is a significant honor bestowed upon the truly elite.
1st ballot
Without a doubt.
Should the Habs retire his jersey? That’s up for debate.
Easily. 4th best all time (fight me), and the best to never win a cup. If Hank gets in, so will Price.