Mastodon
@Edmonton Oilers

DOES McDAVID DESERVE BLAME FOR OILERS’ STRUGGLES? 7-Eleven That’s Hockey



Gino Reda, Dave Poulin, and Frankie Corrado discuss if Connor McDavids ‘lack’ of production can be blamed for the struggles of the Edmonton Oilers.

45 Comments

  1. What else can he do ? Even if he scores 200pts they still have nobody in net that can stop a beach ball.

  2. You guys are missing the point, the oilers have always been designed to play an all out offensive style game, the fact that the GM didn’t fix the starting goaltending issue over the off season is why they are where they are, fire the GM and get a top five goalie, Skinner and Campbell are backup goalies at best. The star players have no confidence in their current goalies and it shows.

  3. Same story every season, throw goalies under the bus. Whole organization is to blame, stop using goalies as a scapegoat. No one saying goalies have been good, it's not the only reason though why Oilers are bad.

  4. The bottom line is the oilers can't expect 1 or 2 maybe 3 players to carry a entire team…regardless if he is dropping off he's still on pace to be & remain a 100 point player. He's giving you the value of the contract you signed him but the other then McDavid & drisedel(lol I know his name is wrong lol) they have to be able to produce other offense besides those 2 players because if either one gets hurt then what? Not to mention their defense isn't good & there goalie is terrible they may not want to but they may have to make a few big trades to find 2 young almost nhl or nhl level goaltenders or prospects because that's how st louis won the cup in 2019 we had 2 nhl level goaltenders split games & it worked because neither goaltenders were tired & they kept switching them out so they both were fresh for each game they played

  5. McDavid or McInjured? I think he is probably still being affected by the injury he had earlier in the season. There's no way this is the same McDavid from last year.

  6. Mcdavid needs to be more of a leader. We don’t see behind the scenes but on the ice & on the bench he needs to get the boys going!!

  7. Bottom line hes got to play better defensively. Scoring two goals and being minus three is wild, being bottom three in plus minus you are a big part of the problem, even if you are the best player. Lead by example, play with the same tenacity on defense as offense for a stretch of games and show your teammates some heart.

  8. Absolutely he does, him and Leon have been beer league defensively and I’m quite sick of all the press focusing on 2 players only with this team………maybe teammates are as well?!

  9. Absolutely he's been really bad, definetly playing outside of himself. Very unusual for such a great player I can't recall guys like Jagr or Gretzky ever having struggles quite like this.

  10. His nickname is "Dash", and not because he's fast.

    He's a "-" in the +/- every single night because he's a defensive liability. He's not a complete hockey player.

  11. Hyman 10 goals
    Kane 8 goals
    Leon
    Mcdavid on every power play has 6 goals. I’d say there is a problem not the only problem but he’s definitely not a plus player.

  12. Yes, 100 percent. He has the C. It's his team. Therefore, it's on him to be a leader. And stop being a Lil emotional skid. Big boys pants on.
    9 years. Yes, it's on him. And if he ever requests a trade, that's him quitting. Plus, you can't win a cup with 2 players making over 10 million. It's facts

  13. Ever since he got in the league, every time he is on the ice, or atleast once or twice a PERIOD, he was getting a breakaway or making a highlight reel play. He’s had that maybeee 5 times this year, he is either hurt or mentally hurt. Mcdavid, what’s wrong!?

  14. If you are having to rely on a player getting 2ppg in order for your team to win your team is poorly constructed and pathetic. That's on the GM and owner.

  15. last 2 games are what happens every game

    1st goal, PISS POOR defensive work by Kulak leaving his man, NOT the goalies fault
    2nd goal was Ekholm coughing up the puck and a 2 on 1 NOT the goalie faults
    3rd goal was piss poor work on the board by Broberg with a soft as F turn over AND again NOT the goalies fault
    4th goal OH LOOK it was Leon with a shocking pass and Mcdavid coughing it up behind the net and them on a breakaway goal, NOT the goalies fault
    5th goal where do i on that shit show of 3 players standing watching a rebound and letting the player just skate right by for a tanks lads i will have that goal. AGAIN not the goalies fault, oh wait closer look it was 4 players and number 27, 5, 29 AND 97, i mean yeah all the gaolies fault.
    6th goal, bouchard and ekholm both in no mans land with a massive wide open gap for the goalie to get scored on or take shots.

    my 9 year old son has a better D game than the whole oilers team right now and thats a Fact, not a joke a FACT yet screw it lets blame the goalies its easier than go against the narrative that 97 and 29 are NOT the best inthe world and both will NEVER win a cup.

    start calling it for what it is and who the problem is, watch the videos and replays right on who causes goals ffs

    Oh and the last game before this nurse caused 1 goal and Mcdaivd coughed up the puck 4 times resulting in goals and couldnt be arsed to back check to help his team THEN in the presser hung his team out to dry.

    you folk are clueless are hockey you are nothing more than fan boys at this point, ive been calling these 2 out since they started playing together on there shit shows and year after yearr top of thew points for themselvves but on team points and give aways resulting in goals agianst there team both AGAIN in the top 10 worse players for it

    shit is game after game yet the fan boys year after year. its been like this since the get go of both coming into the NHL and NOBODY seems to care till now,

    he isnt a GOAT contender at all and never will be and he will NEVER win a cup, neither of them will

  16. 97 and 29 absolutely refuse to play defence. Anyone who thinks 97 is the best player in the world is a crack head. Best players in the world play 200 foot games.

  17. I do not think he should have the C…. Do not think he has ever been much of a leader, players do not want to follow him as Captain, let him just go out and play his amazing game he is the best at that but leader no way… Pass the C to Leon

  18. Holland your Family is calling ! …….. " I AM RETIRING TO SPEND MORE TIME WITH MY FAMILY " !
    HurryUp and TAKE THE $ 9.2 SLUG WITH YOU !!!!!!!

  19. Absolutely 💯 😂
    He gave the puck away to Winnipeg's Kyle Connor in the playoffs and sulked.
    His defense is good not Bergeron elite however RNH has that elite ability to cover McDavid's defensive shortcomings.
    McDavid, Draisaitl and RNH should be reunited and play together from here on in. RNH is both players two way play glue. Meaning he's aware of his two way play and defensive coverages. RNH will get both players the puck.
    GM Holland must be fired. He cannot make a trade, that's for the next GM (Kieth Gretzky).

  20. He's the captain and face of the team. He has to carry some of the blame. As bad as things are, every time the camera is on him he's pouting around, looking like he feels sorry for himself. Can't do that. He's showing no pride in his team, and they are feeding off that vibe. Maybe he's different in the locker room, but on the ice he's not there mentally at all. Especially shows in his own end.

  21. "Some" blame? Sure, I suppose. When things are this bad, nobody gets a free pass but it's a question of how much. Saying that both he and 29 should be better defensively is both accurate and fair. That has been evident for a while now. Harping about it; especially when the rest of the team is playing at beer league level, is most certainly NOT!

    It's a little bit like complaining that the car windows are dirty when the floor is rusted out, the wheels are missing and the engine is seized.

  22. Bughjstad and Kostin actually contributed, you have Broberg the trip over stick slug, Bouch the timid slug, Nurse the overpaid slug, and Ceci the goal less wonder slug, brown the ghost of slugs past , RNH the ageless slug, Swiss cheese skinner slug, cold soup Campbell slug, Ryan head in the clouds slug = lots of underperforming slugs. What do you think you’re going to get when half the team is slugs 🐌

  23. GM, Coach, Players including the Captain they all share part of the blame… Unless they can make a major move VERY SOON their season is over and the likelihood of resigning Leon and then McJesus in the next two years will be a pipe dream… To me, I will empty out the clip to get the best deal(s) possible in order not to waste this year and even if it doesn't pan out then the plan B will be to eventually recoup the assets given up today AND THEN SOME when trading the two cornerstones in the next couple years… But making no move or lateral moves will be idiotical for the organization at this juncture !!!

    Seriously if I were the GM and I know I will be fired if we do not make the playoffs I sure as hell would give up future assets for returns that may actually turn the season around so it would be nonsensical for Holland to be too picky or make lateral moves bc he will end up fired at years end anyhow!!! At least make one last ditch effort to save his job and perhaps turn into a hero!!!

  24. McDavid is all about speed. What happens with Speed in the NHL as players age. If you do not adapt your game drastically you become ineffective. Ask Crosby and Malkin. I prefer Draisaitl long term to McDavid. More odds of Leon winning a Cup because he can slow down the play like Kucherov and Sid.

Write A Comment