Brodeur fans: dude 125 shut outs, 3 Stanley cups, 2 Olympic golds, 4 Vezinas, every possible record a goalie could have regarding games players, wins, even losses and goals scored. I don’t care that somebody was fancier or more exciting. Marty got the job done better than anyone.
mrg3392
Roy, Hasek, Brodeur all have legitimate cases for being greatest of all time it’s a fun debate. Roy has by far the most playoff wins (likely will never be broken), dominant in playoffs leading to his 3 Conn Smythes which is another record. Hasek had insane SP% while playing on not so great teams. Then you have Brodeur who has the all time Wins, Shutouts, Games played but you could argue he played on a great trap team during his career. Crazy how all 3 played each other for many years.
Neely67
Amazing goalie. He did have arguably the best defensive team in front of him (neutral zone trap) certainly of that era.
87lane
You forgot the word second
SwagOD_FPS
Uncle Daddy
mountains_forever
I think it’s Roy. His dominance in the playoffs, when it counted is unmatched.
However. When it was the Avs playing Hasek or Brodeur, I would have rather played Brodeur. I was terrified of Hasek.
the_figureh3ad
Hasek, Roy, Brodeur
Boom_ca
Why is Eddie Belfour never in this conversation? Easily one of the most clutch goaltenders of all time and arguably has the best clutch statistics for the playoffs
greenpill98
“Martin Brodeur” is a funny way to spell Patrick Roy, but it’s a common mistake.
SpiderSens18
Hasek might’ve had a sub 1.50 GAA on those devils teams
14 Comments
Except he’s not the best of all time…..
*Dominik Hasek enters the chat*
Damn look how tiny his pads were
Roy was better. 🤷🏻♂️
Ransoms: but [enter names]
Brodeur fans: dude 125 shut outs, 3 Stanley cups, 2 Olympic golds, 4 Vezinas, every possible record a goalie could have regarding games players, wins, even losses and goals scored. I don’t care that somebody was fancier or more exciting. Marty got the job done better than anyone.
Roy, Hasek, Brodeur all have legitimate cases for being greatest of all time it’s a fun debate. Roy has by far the most playoff wins (likely will never be broken), dominant in playoffs leading to his 3 Conn Smythes which is another record. Hasek had insane SP% while playing on not so great teams. Then you have Brodeur who has the all time Wins, Shutouts, Games played but you could argue he played on a great trap team during his career. Crazy how all 3 played each other for many years.
Amazing goalie. He did have arguably the best defensive team in front of him (neutral zone trap) certainly of that era.
You forgot the word second
Uncle Daddy
I think it’s Roy. His dominance in the playoffs, when it counted is unmatched.
However. When it was the Avs playing Hasek or Brodeur, I would have rather played Brodeur. I was terrified of Hasek.
Hasek, Roy, Brodeur
Why is Eddie Belfour never in this conversation? Easily one of the most clutch goaltenders of all time and arguably has the best clutch statistics for the playoffs
“Martin Brodeur” is a funny way to spell Patrick Roy, but it’s a common mistake.
Hasek might’ve had a sub 1.50 GAA on those devils teams