Personally Crosby. His track record speaks for itself.
ConsiderationPrior93
Crosby or McDavid, and then pair them with one or both of these promising rookies!
FordPrefect-HHGTTG
As…a Wings fan…this kills me…
Prime Crosby is the answer here.
2007-2011…he was a bit of a tool, but he led a great squad for a decade plus and remained great after serious injuries.
If I have to pick right bow, it’s McDavid…I mean…cmon? Obviously
Accomplished_Ad_5719
Crosby is top 5 all time, so that speaks for itself
SVTour07
Guy on the left already proved himself…prime, i`d go with that one
Mitcheeeey
Mcdavid
spence4101
Cros, be serious
subhuman09
I’ll take the three Stanley Cups
ResponsibilityNo3935
Is the michkov thing a troll?
RaidenDoesReddit
Sid the kid pre injuries? Yeah I fucking take that guy boss
REAPER-1_xxx
Whichever has a competent GM.
NightHaunted
If we’re taking them as a day one rookie with knowledge of what they’re truly capable of becoming I’m taking Crosby and then paying some big fucking dudes to protect him the way Pittsburgh didn’t.
Havoc_XXI
Crosby, hands down. I’m really not sold on Bedard yet. I could be completely and totally wrong here.
cascadiacurmedgeon
Two of these guys have not even played an NHL game…
Crosby is the most complete player of his generation with a guaranteed first-ballot HOF resume
McDavid is the most skilled player since Jagr (potentially going to enter Lemieux/Gretzky territory soon?) but until him and pissy old Leon can prove it by dragging the team to a championship, I would take Crosby any day.
Hopefully this comment ages poorly, and Bedard is as good as advertised, but I will always reserve my opinion on any “next one” until they have had a few years in the league to show us what they can really do.
Also hope Michkov is someone the Flyers can build around but we’ll have to wait and see…
Oilerfan87
Michkov? Lol
KaneAndShane
Crosby because he’s proven himself by leading his team to three cup wins. McDavid is an obvious second. Bedard has great potential but has to prove himself. I had to Google Michkov.
plastic_sun
Crosby.
McDavid is the best player skill wise but has not proven to be a leader.
Bedard and Michkov, not proven yet, but Bedard seems to have the best attitude between the two, which can make the difference long term.
oakandbarrel
Crosby is a complete winner and is top 5 all time. Mcdavid will be the best player to never win a cup. Bedard is promising, but so was Lafreniere – can’t build my team on possibilities. Michkov won’t even be top 10 Russian all time.
LukeyMagukey
Crosby😤, Mcdavid😤, Michkov😛, Bedard😤
sneakyfingers45
Crosby is the only winner in the bunch, so him
createdrandom81
Sid 100%
Motivated78
We can all see how that’s going with McDavid….
Whadyagot
87
Cultural-Loss-855
I don’t understand how Crosby is in this discussion, he has three cups and has proven everything he was hyped to be. The other guys are amazing but Crosby has already done it. And a OT gold medal goal on top of it!
hoselrocket-
crosby…
easy choice.
kingmidas312
Bedard hasn’t even played his first nhl game yet chill y’all 😂😂
FishBobinski
87. C’mon now.
Dice7
Give me Michkov. #teamchaos
ogfuelbone12
Crosby EZ
Shawnaldo7575
Going off board… Phil Kessel.
BraveSirRyan
Crosby.
OHL0NGJ0HNSON
The one with 3 Stanley Cups
Putting Michkov in here is cringe btw
ManOfTheHillls
3 cups vs best player in this era vs generational talent vs Michkov. Hmm. Michkov lol
How about we at least throw Ovechkin or Matthews or heck even Mackinnon there to balance out the options? Love Michkov but the choice is too easily Mcdavid or Crosby
Dyldo_II
Bro Bedard hasn’t even played a game in the NHL. I’m as excited for him as the next guy, but let him learn the ropes first
The same goes for Michkov
chipcity90
0 appreciation for P. Kane.
johnnymavrigg
Right now? Or in their primes? In their primes I’ll say Crosby because just a great all around player and good team leader and winner at every level.
36 Comments
Personally Crosby. His track record speaks for itself.
Crosby or McDavid, and then pair them with one or both of these promising rookies!
As…a Wings fan…this kills me…
Prime Crosby is the answer here.
2007-2011…he was a bit of a tool, but he led a great squad for a decade plus and remained great after serious injuries.
If I have to pick right bow, it’s McDavid…I mean…cmon? Obviously
Crosby is top 5 all time, so that speaks for itself
Guy on the left already proved himself…prime, i`d go with that one
Mcdavid
Cros, be serious
I’ll take the three Stanley Cups
Is the michkov thing a troll?
Sid the kid pre injuries? Yeah I fucking take that guy boss
Whichever has a competent GM.
If we’re taking them as a day one rookie with knowledge of what they’re truly capable of becoming I’m taking Crosby and then paying some big fucking dudes to protect him the way Pittsburgh didn’t.
Crosby, hands down. I’m really not sold on Bedard yet. I could be completely and totally wrong here.
Two of these guys have not even played an NHL game…
Crosby is the most complete player of his generation with a guaranteed first-ballot HOF resume
McDavid is the most skilled player since Jagr (potentially going to enter Lemieux/Gretzky territory soon?) but until him and pissy old Leon can prove it by dragging the team to a championship, I would take Crosby any day.
Hopefully this comment ages poorly, and Bedard is as good as advertised, but I will always reserve my opinion on any “next one” until they have had a few years in the league to show us what they can really do.
Also hope Michkov is someone the Flyers can build around but we’ll have to wait and see…
Michkov? Lol
Crosby because he’s proven himself by leading his team to three cup wins. McDavid is an obvious second. Bedard has great potential but has to prove himself. I had to Google Michkov.
Crosby.
McDavid is the best player skill wise but has not proven to be a leader.
Bedard and Michkov, not proven yet, but Bedard seems to have the best attitude between the two, which can make the difference long term.
Crosby is a complete winner and is top 5 all time. Mcdavid will be the best player to never win a cup. Bedard is promising, but so was Lafreniere – can’t build my team on possibilities. Michkov won’t even be top 10 Russian all time.
Crosby😤, Mcdavid😤, Michkov😛, Bedard😤
Crosby is the only winner in the bunch, so him
Sid 100%
We can all see how that’s going with McDavid….
87
I don’t understand how Crosby is in this discussion, he has three cups and has proven everything he was hyped to be. The other guys are amazing but Crosby has already done it. And a OT gold medal goal on top of it!
crosby…
easy choice.
Bedard hasn’t even played his first nhl game yet chill y’all 😂😂
87. C’mon now.
Give me Michkov. #teamchaos
Crosby EZ
Going off board… Phil Kessel.
Crosby.
The one with 3 Stanley Cups
Putting Michkov in here is cringe btw
3 cups vs best player in this era vs generational talent vs Michkov. Hmm. Michkov lol
How about we at least throw Ovechkin or Matthews or heck even Mackinnon there to balance out the options? Love Michkov but the choice is too easily Mcdavid or Crosby
Bro Bedard hasn’t even played a game in the NHL. I’m as excited for him as the next guy, but let him learn the ropes first
The same goes for Michkov
0 appreciation for P. Kane.
Right now? Or in their primes? In their primes I’ll say Crosby because just a great all around player and good team leader and winner at every level.